argument: Notizie/News - Ethics and Philosophy of Law
Source: Bloomberg Law
The Justice Department’s Office of Professional Responsibility concluded that two department attorneys violated professional-conduct rules through their use of artificial intelligence. In the first matter, OPR said an attorney submitted an AI-generated brief containing fabricated quotations and subsequently made false statements to the court about the brief. OPR determined that the first attorney breached professional obligations knowingly and intentionally. In the second matter, an attorney uploaded documents to a public AI platform contrary to a tribunal’s protective order. OPR found that the second attorney acted recklessly in violating professional-conduct rules and also breached DOJ policy and the protective order.
Both attorneys were referred to DOJ’s Professional Misconduct Review Unit following the investigations. The review unit can make recommendations to state bar authorities, and the report describes potential bar discipline. OPR published the investigation findings in anonymized summaries. Bloomberg Law said the first case summary matched its reporting about North Carolina assistant US attorney Rudy Renfer. According to that reporting, Renfer was fired in March and later formally reprimanded by a judge for submitting the AI-generated brief while defending the government against a lawsuit and failing to be candid with the court about his actions.