argument: Notizie/News - AI in Judicial Activities
Source: KQED
More than one-third of civil lawsuits filed in 2026 in Santa Clara and San Francisco counties, excluding debt collection cases, show signs of AI-assisted writing, according to a Stanford University report. Researchers from Stanford’s Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence and Regulation, Evaluation, and Governance lab examined AI use in state trial courts. In Santa Clara, the proportion of complaints filed by people representing themselves that showed AI indicators rose from 19% in 2024 to 72% in 2026. Approximately one-third of attorney-filed complaints in Santa Clara also showed such indicators. These estimates concern detected signs of AI assistance; the researchers noted that general-language detectors struggle with legal vocabulary and standard wording. The researchers calibrated their detectors using nearly 1,000 actual court filings in which judges had identified fabricated citations, while acknowledging that detection could become harder as models better imitate human writing.
The study authors suggested that AI could improve access to legal expertise while increasing case volumes, document lengths and the risk of fictitious citations or facts. Stanford law professor and study co-author Dan Ho also warned that AI could produce unreliable legal arguments without inventing a case. Ho nevertheless suggested that AI could improve complaints for people with limited access to legal knowledge. Stanford HAI policy fellow Riana Pfefferkorn, who did not participate in the study, emphasized that AI use alone establishes neither document quality nor better litigation outcomes. UC Berkeley law professor Colleen Chien noted that the study cannot distinguish people replacing affordable legal representation from people who would otherwise never have brought a case. UC Law San Francisco professor Robin Feldman predicted more material and declining quality, while acknowledging that AI could help people unable to afford lawyers understand and pursue legal claims.