argument: Notizie/News - Civil Procedure Law
Source: Local Government Lawyer
The High Court awarded two self-represented litigants £1,488 for an AI legal research subscription, accepting the expense as a reasonably and proportionately incurred disbursement. Linda Foster and Richard Hitchens had successfully appealed a possession order obtained by Wargrave on Thames Housing Association Ltd over their flat. The dispute concerned the interpretation of an electricity charge in their tenancy agreement, and the costs decision arose in Foster & Hitchens v Wargrave on Thames Housing Association Ltd [2026] EWHC 3000 (KB). The appellants sought reimbursement for twelve monthly subscription payments of £124 and said the software helped them locate authorities, research legal issues and prepare submissions. Mr Justice Sweeting rejected their argument that the subscription constituted payment for legal services, explaining that the platform supported their own work without supplying qualified legal advice or transferring responsibility for their submissions to the provider.
The housing association argued that the subscription was an overhead and that reimbursement would improperly expand recoverable litigation expenses. The judge distinguished general infrastructure spending from support obtained for particular proceedings and applied existing costs principles without creating a special rule for AI. The judge noted that the subscription provided a sector-specific AI agent, was not maintained for other purposes and supported submissions that were focused and successful on the main issue. Although the judge allowed the subscription expense in full, the judge stressed that AI support costs are not automatically recoverable and warned that excessive, unhelpful AI-generated material could lead to their rejection. Separately, the judge reduced the appellants’ claim for 649 hours of their own work to £5,600, approximately 40% of the amount claimed.