argument: Notizie/News - AI in Judicial Activities
Source: 24Law
The Madhya Pradesh High Court criticised the State Government for citing a nonexistent Supreme Court decision, observing that unverified AI use apparently explained the error. Justice Vivek Kumar Singh addressed the citation while hearing Piyush Mani Tiwari’s challenge to dismissal from the police service. The State invoked State of Andhra Pradesh v. S.S. Mohammad Nisar, purportedly reported at (2008) 5 SCC 230, to support an argument about judicial review of evidence. The court found that the cited decision did not exist and that the reference belonged to Sidhartha Vashisht @ Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi), concerning suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal. The court emphasised the professional obligation to check legal authorities and required the Advocate General’s office to verify propositions and citations before affidavits were filed. The court also directed that its judgment be sent to the Principal Secretary, Law Department, and the Advocate General.
A woman cleaner had accused Tiwari of indecent behaviour on 26 May 2024; Tiwari was suspended that day and dismissed the following day without a departmental inquiry. Tiwari challenged the absence of procedural safeguards, while the State argued that distress, public outrage, police discipline and possible witness intimidation justified dispensing with an inquiry. The court found no material establishing threats or intimidation and noted that the State had not produced a contemporaneous record explaining why an inquiry could not reasonably be held. The court quashed the dismissal order of 27 May 2024 and the departmental appellate order of 22 July 2024, directing immediate reinstatement. The competent authority remained free to conduct a regular departmental inquiry under the applicable Madhya Pradesh service rules, with a reasonable opportunity for Tiwari to be heard. Back wages and consequential benefits would depend on the outcome of any inquiry; the court expressly left the merits of the misconduct allegations undecided.