AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence LawCC BY-NC-SA Commercial Licence ISSN 3035-5451
G. Giappichelli Editore

19/11/2026 - Nonexistent Cases Found in Romanian Lawyer’s AI-Assisted Submissions to Human Rights Court (International)

argument: Notizie/News - AI in Judicial Activities

Source: Anadolu Agency

A Romanian lawyer has been excluded for two years from representing or assisting litigants before the European Court of Human Rights after submitting unchecked case-law references generated by AI, according to the court’s registry. The court’s president approved the measure on November 13 after a chamber identified references to cases that did not exist and fabricated paragraphs attributed to actual judgments. The chamber also found that some cited decisions had no relevance to the arguments or contradicted the positions they were cited to support.

The lawyer acknowledged using AI to prepare the submissions and described the mistakes as inaccuracies and citation errors. The chamber found recurring substantive mistakes and concluded that the lawyer had not fulfilled her professional and ethical obligations. It said the lawyer should have verified the AI-generated references and arguments using authoritative sources, including HUDOC, the court’s database. Some references had received no verification. The chamber concluded that the errors impaired the administration of justice because the court had to devote considerable time to checking the submissions and conducting the exclusion proceedings.