AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence LawCC BY-NC-SA Commercial Licence ISSN 3035-5451
G. Giappichelli Editore

16/11/2025 - Over-Reliance on AI Undermines Injured Worker's Credibility in Court (USA)

argument: Notizie/News - Labor Law / Employment Law

Source: WorkersCompensation.com

WorkersCompensation.com reports on a federal court case where an injured worker's credibility was significantly damaged due to an over-reliance on artificial intelligence in presenting their claim. The worker submitted documentation and testimony that appeared to be heavily influenced or directly generated by an AI program. The court noted inconsistencies, a lack of personal detail, and formulaic language in the submissions, which raised doubts about the authenticity and accuracy of the worker's own account of their injuries and limitations.

The judge in the case specifically commented on the worker's use of AI, suggesting that it obscured the genuine facts and undermined the claimant's persuasiveness. The ruling serves as a stark warning about the potential dangers of using generative AI to prepare legal arguments or personal testimony without careful review and personalization. While technology can assist in organizing information, this case demonstrates that relying too heavily on it can backfire, particularly in legal arenas like workers' compensation where claimant credibility is often a central issue. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of authentic, first-hand accounts in legal proceedings.