AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence LawCC BY-NC-SA Commercial Licence ISSN 3035-5451
G. Giappichelli Editore

12/11/2025 - AI Misuse by Lawyer Prompts Client to Request Self-Representation (USA)

argument: Notizie/News - AI in Judicial Activities

Source: FOX10tv

FOX10tv reports a dramatic development in a federal case in Mobile, Alabama, where a defendant accused of being a "kingpin" has requested to dismiss his attorney and represent himself. The request comes after it was revealed that his lawyer had used an artificial intelligence program to help prepare court filings, which resulted in significant errors and "hallucinations," including the citation of non-existent cases. The defendant expressed a complete loss of trust in his legal counsel's ability to effectively represent him.

This case highlights the serious real-world consequences for clients when their lawyers misuse generative AI. The defendant's motion to proceed "pro se" (representing oneself) complicates the criminal proceedings and raises questions about the lawyer's professional competence and ethical obligations. The judge must now consider the defendant's request and address the legal fallout from the attorney's AI-related errors, an issue that is becoming increasingly common in courtrooms across the country and which directly impacts the right to effective assistance of counsel.