AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence LawCC BY-NC-SA Commercial Licence ISSN 3035-5451
G. Giappichelli Editore

21/09/2025 - AI Art and Copyright: An Illustrator's Style Replication Sparks Debate (USA)

argument: Notizie/News - Intellectual Property Law

Source: ABC 7 Chicago

ABC 7 Chicago covers the story of Wheaton, Illinois illustrator Jason Seiler, who claims an award-winning, AI-generated image unlawfully replicated his distinctive caricature style. Seiler, known for his cover art for publications like Time Magazine, argues that the AI-generated portrait, which won a photography contest, was so similar to his work that many people initially thought he was the creator. This incident has ignited a significant debate about the intersection of artificial intelligence, artistic creation, and the current state of copyright law.

The report, by John Garcia, delves into the legal ambiguities surrounding AI-generated art. While copyright law protects specific expressions of an idea, it does not typically protect an artist's "style." This case raises new questions about whether the law needs to evolve to address situations where AI models are trained on an artist's portfolio to produce works that are derivative in style, if not in direct content. Legal experts interviewed for the story suggest that this area is a developing frontier for intellectual property law, with artists like Seiler left wondering what legal recourse they have to protect their unique artistic identities from being mimicked by algorithms.