AI Law - International Review of Artificial Intelligence LawCC BY-NC-SA Commercial Licence ISSN 3035-5451
G. Giappichelli Editore

12/09/2025 - The Reliability of AI Book Summaries: A Critical Examination

argument: Notizie/News - Intellectual Property Law

Source: Qazinform

Qazinform critically examines the growing trend of using artificial intelligence to generate book summaries, questioning their reliability and potential impact on reading culture. The article, referencing a piece from Kazinform, explores both the utility and the significant drawbacks of these AI-powered tools. On one hand, they offer undeniable convenience, providing time-pressed individuals with quick overviews of lengthy texts, which can be useful for academic research or for deciding whether to commit to reading a full book. These summaries can distill key plot points, character arcs, and central themes into a concise format. The technology behind these tools has become increasingly sophisticated, allowing for more coherent and seemingly comprehensive rundowns of complex narratives and non-fiction arguments. This accessibility is seen as a major advantage in an age of information overload.

However, the article raises serious concerns about the accuracy and depth of AI-generated summaries. A primary issue is "context collapse," where the nuances, subtleties, and emotional depth of the original text are lost in the process of algorithmic condensation. AI models may struggle to grasp irony, satire, or the author's unique voice, leading to summaries that are factually correct on a surface level but fail to capture the essence of the work. Furthermore, the potential for factual inaccuracies and "hallucinations"—where the AI invents details not present in the source material—is a significant problem. The piece also touches upon the intellectual property implications, as the creation of derivative summaries raises questions about copyright infringement. Ultimately, the article suggests a cautious approach, positioning AI summaries as a potential supplement to, but not a replacement for, the immersive and intellectually rewarding experience of reading a book in its entirety.